Skip to content
DataRemote
Press

When the Copper Line Goes Dark, Who's Liable?

Adapted from Forbes Business Council

Timor Brik 9 min read
A white balance scale on a dark background, tipped toward a solid red pan on the left, with a severed gray line running along the ground beneath it.

Direct Answer

When a copper line serving an elevator phone, fire alarm panel, or other life-safety device stops working, liability usually lands on whoever owns or controls that system under the lease, the monitoring contract, the insurance policy, and the applicable code, and in many buildings those point at different parties. DataRemote COO Timor Brik argues that organizations should settle who is accountable before carriers retire the line, by naming one owner, inventorying every copper-dependent system, confirming the replacement with the inspector early, and documenting the plan.

Key Takeaways

  • Copper retirement is usually framed as a technology or cost decision. It is also a governance and liability decision, because many of the lines still in service carry life-safety signals.
  • The FCC’s March 2026 Network and Services Modernization Order removed much of the lead time organizations used to get, which makes “we didn’t know” a weaker position.
  • Carrier notices often go to a billing or headquarters address, not to the person responsible for elevator phones and alarm panels.
  • In shared buildings, the elevator, the alarm line, the telecom contract, and the monitoring service can each belong to a different party.
  • Four documents decide most of the exposure: leases, monitoring contracts, insurance policies, and carrier accounts.
  • One accountable owner, a complete inventory, early contact with the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ), and a written migration plan are the core of a defensible position.

Timor Brik grew up in South Africa, where copper theft and the brownouts and blackouts that followed were part of daily life. When the lines went quiet, so did the homes, businesses, and emergency services that depended on them. In his November 2026 Forbes Business Council article, he borrows a question attorney Matthew Erskine raised about artificial intelligence (if something goes badly wrong, who answers for it?) and asks it of the landline instead.

Most coverage of copper retirement treats it as a necessary technology swap. Brik’s argument is that when a line connected to an elevator phone or a fire alarm panel stops working, the first question isn’t what replaces it. It’s who is liable.

This page adapts that article and extends it with the regulatory sources, a responsibility map, and a documentation checklist.

Why copper retirement became a liability question

For years, copper retirements came with time to prepare. Carriers filed with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the public could comment, and anyone in an affected area could plan months or years ahead.

That window has narrowed. The FCC adopted the Network and Services Modernization Order on March 26, 2026. According to the Commission’s fact sheet for the order, it:

  • Eliminates all filing requirements in the network change disclosure rules
  • Consolidates technology-transition discontinuance applications under one rule
  • Applies a 31-day automatic grant period to discontinuance applications
  • Treats state and local requirements that conflict with the federal discontinuance framework as subject to preemption

The carriers are using that framework. AT&T has told customers that copper landline service is likely to be discontinued at wire centers across 18 states starting in November, and the filings behind it are recorded in DataRemote’s newsroom record of AT&T’s November 15 shutdown. Verizon has asked the FCC to retire copper-based service at roughly 750,000 locations in nine states and the District of Columbia. More carriers and more filings will follow; the FCC copper retirement rules page tracks the framework they file under.

Brik’s point is that this changes the legal posture. When copper retirement is widely reported and carriers move on shorter timelines, an organization’s ignorance of a shutdown becomes a weak defense. And the warning, when it comes, may be sent to the address the carrier has on file, which is often a billing address at headquarters rather than the person responsible for life-safety systems.

A dead line is a compliance event

Copper still carries signals many organizations never think of as telecom. Most of them are life-safety or security functions where a working line can matter in an emergency.

SystemWhat stops workingExposure
Elevator emergency phoneTwo-way calls from the carFailed inspection; elevator out of service; a trapped passenger
Fire alarm panelSignals to the supervising stationFailed inspection; insurance claims
Burglar alarm panelIntrusion signalsMonitoring and insurance terms
Call boxes and building entryCalls for help from gates and lobbiesNegligence claims
Access controlLink to its management serviceUnnoticed security gaps
Regulated fax linesDocument transmissionRecords obligations

The requirements behind the first two rows come from the codes that govern them: ASME A17.1/CSA B44 for elevator emergency communication, and NFPA 72 for fire alarm signal transmission, as adopted and enforced by the local authority.

Brik lists four fronts where that gap turns into exposure: a failed inspection, an elevator that can no longer legally operate, an insurer rejecting a claim, and a negligence suit after someone couldn’t call for help.

Replacing the line doesn’t close the gap on its own. A replacement that doesn’t work with the alarm panel, or that has no backup power, may leave the same exposure in place under a different invoice.

What the FCC means by an adequate replacement

The FCC has a defined standard for this. Under the test it adopted in 2016, a carrier’s technology-transition discontinuance can be expedited when the adequate replacement it points to:

  1. Keeps network performance, reliability, and coverage substantially unchanged for customers
  2. Meets current rules and standards for 911 access, cybersecurity, and access for people with disabilities
  3. Stays compatible with a defined list of legacy services still used by consumers and small businesses, including home security systems and medical monitoring devices

That standard governs the carrier’s application, not the building owner’s obligations. It’s still a useful yardstick for anyone choosing a replacement: if the new path can’t match the old one on reliability, on enhanced 911, or on compatibility with the devices actually plugged into it, the organization has inherited a problem rather than solved one.

Who owns the line? Responsibility in shared buildings

Ownership is where the liability question gets hard, because the parties connected to a single copper line often never coordinated.

  • The landlord or building owner may own the elevator and its emergency phone.
  • An individual tenant may pay for the alarm line serving its own space.
  • A property manager or board member may have signed the telecom contract years ago and moved on since.
  • The monitoring company may assume the line exists without being responsible for providing it.
  • The carrier sends its discontinuance notice to the account holder of record, who may be none of the above.

Each party can reasonably believe someone else is watching the line. That’s how a building ends up with a dead elevator phone and no one who knew the notice arrived. The building owner’s guide to the AT&T copper shutdown covers how these responsibilities typically split in commercial property.

Four documents to review with counsel

Brik recommends that leaders and their counsel review four kinds of documents. The question each one should answer:

DocumentThe question to answer
LeasesWho pays for, maintains, and is responsible for building systems such as elevators, fire alarms, and emergency call boxes?
Monitoring contractsWhat happens to the monitoring obligation when the connection type changes from copper to something else?
Insurance policiesDoes coverage, or a premium discount, depend on a functioning alarm communication path?
Carrier accountsWhere do carrier notices go, and does that address reach the person responsible for life-safety lines?

Gaps between these documents are where liability tends to collect. A lease that assigns the elevator to the landlord, a telecom account in a former manager’s name, and a monitoring contract silent on connection changes can leave every party with an argument and the building with no working line.

What to do before the letter arrives

Brik’s earlier Forbes article made the case that the end of copper is a strategic inflection point, not just a technical upgrade. His prescription here is about governance:

  1. Assign one accountable owner. Copper migration touches facilities, IT, legal, finance, and risk. Name one person or team responsible for life-safety lines and for carrier notices.
  2. Inventory. Identify every system and service that still depends on a copper landline, including security alarms, payment terminals, fax machines, elevator phones, and emergency communication lines. The complete guide to POTS line replacement walks through a site-by-site inventory.
  3. Involve the inspector early. Confirm the replacement approach with the authority having jurisdiction before installation, not at inspection.
  4. Document. A documented migration plan shows diligence and may support an affirmative defense if something later fails.

What to keep on file

A useful record for each site includes: the named owner, the inventory of copper-dependent systems, every carrier notice received and the date it arrived, the AHJ’s written confirmation of the replacement approach, per-line test results after cutover, and the dated migration plan. For elevator phones and alarm panels, test results should name who confirmed the signal at the receiving end; the elevator emergency phone guide explains what that test should cover.

How DataRemote helps

DataRemote builds POTS IN A BOX® appliances that connect in place of the copper line on the existing panel or phone and carry its signal over managed cellular, so the elevator phone, alarm panel, or call box can keep working without being replaced. Supported models include battery backup rated for up to 24 to 48 hours of standby, depending on model, configuration, and load, and certification records for each model are published on the compliance page.

For documentation, the Ara platform shows line status across every site, so a line that stops responding is visible before an inspection or an emergency finds it. The fire and burglar alarm communication and elevator emergency communication pages cover how each endpoint is migrated, and POTS line replacement covers the broader program.

Start with the inventory

DataRemote can help you identify which lines in your portfolio carry life-safety signals and plan their migration before a carrier’s notice sets the date. Talk to our team.

A governance decision, not just a technology one

The copper sunset is usually framed as a cost or technology decision. Brik’s conclusion is that it is also a governance decision. Organizations that treat the transition as a legal risk now still get to choose their replacement path and their timeline. Those that wait may find the decision made for them by a carrier’s notice and, in the worst case, by a court.

This article is general information based on the author’s opinion and is not legal advice. Organizations should consult counsel about their specific obligations.

View as Markdown

Frequently Asked Questions

There is no single answer, which is the problem. Responsibility usually follows who owns or controls the system and what the lease, monitoring contract, insurance policy, and carrier account say. In a multi-tenant building those can point at different parties: the landlord may own the elevator while a tenant pays for the alarm line. Brik's recommendation is to settle that question with counsel before a line fails, not after.

On March 26, 2026, the FCC adopted the Network and Services Modernization Order. According to the Commission's fact sheet, it eliminates the filing requirements in the network change disclosure rules, consolidates technology-transition discontinuance applications under one rule, applies a 31-day automatic grant period to discontinuance applications, and treats conflicting state and local requirements as subject to preemption. Less lead time and wider public reporting both make it harder to argue a shutdown came without warning.

Under the test the FCC adopted in 2016, a technology-transition discontinuance can be expedited when the replacement keeps network performance, reliability, and coverage substantially unchanged; meets current rules for 911 access, cybersecurity, and access for people with disabilities; and stays compatible with a defined list of legacy services, including home security systems and medical monitoring devices. A replacement that cannot carry an alarm panel's signal, or that loses power in an outage, may not solve the problem the copper line used to solve.

To whatever address the carrier has on file for the account. That is often a headquarters or billing address rather than the person responsible for the building's life-safety systems, so a notice can arrive and never reach anyone who acts on it. Checking the notice and contact details on every carrier account is one of the four reviews Brik recommends.

A named owner for life-safety lines, an inventory of every copper-dependent system, the carrier notices received and when, written confirmation of the replacement approach from the authority having jurisdiction, test results for each migrated line, and a dated migration plan. Brik notes that a documented plan shows diligence and may support a defense if something later fails; whether it does in a particular case is a question for counsel.

Map your copper risk before the carrier's notice arrives

Talk to DataRemote about inventorying life-safety lines and moving them to managed cellular on a timeline you control.

Keep reading

Suggested posts